Requirements for Recovery of Consequential Damages The degree of proof as to the amount of damages is high-er for consequential damages than for direct damages, and consequential damages must be pled with greater specificity. In our article, Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements, which was recently published in The Business Lawyer, we provide clarity on the issue of Consequential Damages. One of the most common arguments against pure economic loss is the floodgates principle, which argues that the business world would have to be overly cautious, which isn't a good thing for the economy. Clauses that exclude or limit the recovery of consequential or indirect damages are common in construction, services and other commercial contracts. 2. Posted: 17 Sep 2015, Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP; Texas Tech University School of Law; SMU Dedman School of Law. at 807. Consequential damage waivers are a frequent part of merger and acquisition agreements involving private company targets. In Panasia, the court relied on the same reasoning set forth in Bi-Economy to determine that consequential damages could be awarded. Unlike the … One of the most negotiated issues in construction contracts are liquidated and consequential damages. The recent cases of Hotel Services Limited v Hilton International Hotels (UK) Limited and Deepak Fertilisers v Davy McKee are clear examples of this position. [7] Id. This page was processed by aws-apollo5 in. The words “consequential and special losses” excluded liability only for damages falling within the second limb of the rule in Hadley v Baxendale and therefore claims (ii) and (iii) fell within the first limb. at 792. They are not. This is one of a series of articles originally published in Mealey’s Litigation Report: Insurance Bad Faith, Vol. Id. Posted on July 23, 2008 by Ken Adams. Consequential Damages • Consequential damages are often the most significant and difficult to forecast –enormous risk potential o Example: Perini Corp. v. Great Bay Hotel & Casino, Inc. • Contractor hit with $14,500,000 judgment for consequential damages -25xits Fee!! West, Glenn D. and Duran, Sara, Reassessing the 'Consequences' of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements (May 1, 2008). After tracing the historical derivation of the term, and its current use, we provide a number of basic guidelines for addressing consequential damage waivers in acquisition agreements, which include the following: Posted by Jim Naughton, co-editor, HLS Forum on Corporate Governance and Financial Regulation, on, Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance, on Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements, Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements. To learn more, visit our Cookies page. 2. [6] Id. at 792. Posted August 14, 2017. Therefore, when attempting to prove consequential damages, if a party does not specifically plead those damages, then the evidence of those damages would be inadmissible. Suggested Citation, 767 Fifth AvenueNew York, NY 10153United States214-746-7780 (Phone)214-746-7777 (Fax), 1802 HartfordLubbock, TX 79409United States, One First National PlazaChicago, IL 60603United States, Corporate Law: Corporate & Takeover Law eJournal, Subscribe to this fee journal for more curated articles on this topic, Corporate Governance: Arrangements & Laws eJournal, We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content.By continuing, you agree to the use of cookies. (Click here for a copy.) But this task confounds both lawyers and judges. Loss of profits due to an interruption of normal business practices. Even though consequential damage waivers are a frequent part of merger and acquisition agreements involving private company targets, we believe that few deal professionals understand the concept of consequential damages and, as a result, the inclusion of such waivers may have an unexpected impact on both buyers and sellers. at 791–92 (internal quotation marks and citations omitted). That’s what I did, with an article that I mentioned in this July 2008 blog post as my trusty guide: “Reassessing the ‘Consequences’ of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements,” 63 Business Lawyer 777 (2008). Toll Free: 800.975.9468 (Continued on page 2) Fax: 216.241.4520 Direct Damages, Consequential Damages & Liquidated Damages: A Brief Review by Robert Gavin We often are asked “What is … Although these waivers are heavily negotiated, the authors believe that few deal professionals understand the concept of consequential damages and, as a result, the inclusion of such waivers may have an unexpected impact on both buyers and sellers. [5] Glenn D. West and Sara G. Duran, Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements, 63 The Business Lawyer 777, 780 (May 2008). This post comes from Glenn D. West and Sara G. Duran of Weil, Gotshal & Manges. [6] Id. Consequential damage waivers are a frequent part of merger and acquisition agreements involving private company targets. [8] David Leinwand, Considering the Consequential Damages Waiver, October 2011 Mergers & Acquisitions and Corporate Governance 6. Buyers should avoid including the broad term “lost profits” as a separate category of damages in the waiver provision. [7] Id. What Are Consequential Damages? Disclaimers of Consequential Damages. Cleveland, OH 44114 stand those damages directly related to the design defect. Detriment that arises from the interposition of special, unpredictable circumstances. Although these waivers are heavily negotiated, the authors believe that few deal professionals understand the concept of consequential damages and, as a result, the inclusion of such waivers may have an unexpected impact on both buyers and sellers. consequential upon damage to the Darfur, the owners were not entitled to limit their liability. This page was processed by aws-apollo5 in 0.172 seconds, Using the URL or DOI link below will ensure access to this page indefinitely. 63 Bus. Consequential Consequences: Contractually Excluding Damages for Lost Profits. However, the remote consequences of a defendant’s act or omission cannot form the basis for an award of compensatory damages. If possible, buyers should try to define “consequential damages” for the purpose of any waiver provision in such a manner that the term covers only those consequential damages for which the law already denies recovery for breaches of contract. For example, if a judge applies an exclusion of “consequential damages” on the basis of a particular loss's foreseeability, this could come as quite a surprise to one of the parties if they thought the term limited recovery to just the immediate losses caused by a breach and not any subsequent effects. Consequential damages are also known as “special damages,” and are damages that are not a direct result of an incident itself, but are instead consequences of that incident.An example of consequential damages would be a driver getting into a car accident because, instead of paying attention to the road, he was focused on another car accident that had just happened across the street. [6] Id. at 781. To understand the effects of a consequential damages waiver, one must first understand what consequential damages are. Instead of waiving “consequential” damages, buyers should seek waivers of “remote” or “speculative” damages. The fact that they can be assigned to a wide array of consequences means that the amount of consequential damages that can be awarded to a plaintiff can skyrocket rather quickly. While a plaintiff wants an award, a defendant does not because the indirect results of having breached a contract can have a far-reaching impact on the defendant. Time for Insurers To Face the Consequences of Consequential Damages The First Department issued a clear decision that policyholders may recover the consequential damages… Consequential Damages: a Distinction of Consequence. Prezzybox.com is not liable for product misuse or indirect, special or consequential damages. I use the words “not unlikely” as In such contexts, (a) incidental damages are costs and expenses incurred by the non-breaching party to avoid other direct and consequential losses caused by the breach, and (b) consequential damages are damages that (i) are neither incidental nor direct damages and (i) normally and necessarily arise from the specific nature of either the particular breach or the buyer’s circumstances. Consequential damages, otherwise known as special damages, are damages that can be proven to have occurred because of the failure of one party to meet a contractual obligation, a breach of contract. The confusion comes not from how we are explaining it, but because the word “consequential” to describe a certain category of damages is unfortunate. The May 2008 issue of The Business Lawyer contains a great article by Glenn D. West and Sara G. Duran of Weil Gotshal entitled “Reassessing the ‘Consequences’ of Consequential Damage … 32 Pages 3. Simply put, consequential damages typically are more significant when it comes to the amounts awarded. 5. In our article, Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements, which was recently published in The Business Lawyer, we provide clarity on the issue of Consequential Damages. Home » Incidental Damages vs. It is confusing. Carve outs from the Consequential Damage Disclaimer. The court stated that such “consequential damages” are recoverable if they were contemplated and foreseeable by the parties at the time of contracting and are reasonably ascertainable. at 792. These damages are considered direct if the consequences of the breaching could have been foreseen at the signing of the contract. Some courts have specifically held that many damages categories typically deemed “consequential” are subject to specific pleading requirements, including diminished bonding capacity, lost opportunity, and lost profits. consequential loss or damage, ... (namely, loss which is a direct and natural consequence of the breach). But you may be surprised if you take a closer look at these provisions. Yet some courts follow the Restatement. Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Damage Waivers 779 These clauses are usually found in the miscellaneous provisions of the acquisition agreement or as a specifi c exception to the defi nition of “Losses” applicable to the agreement’s indemnifi cation … Reassessing the "Consequences" of Consequential Damage Waivers 779 These clauses are usually found in the miscellaneous provisions of the acquisition agreement or as a specific exception to the definition of "Losses" applicable to the agreement's indemnification provisions. consequential damages that are recoverable and those that are not. From a legal standpoint, an enforceable contract is present when it is: expressed by a valid offer and acceptance, has adequate consideration, mutual assent, capacity, and legality. In merger and acquisition (“M&A”) transactions, the definitive purchase agreement (whether asset purchase agreement, stock purchase agreement, or merger agreement) typically contains representations and warranties and related indemnification covenants. 7. By Ryan Krushelnitzky. Consequential damages are still proximately caused by the breach, but, under general rules of contract law, are only recoverable if the special circumstances or the other event was foreseeable by the party in breach when it made the contract. In this case, the insured sought direct and consequential damages from its insurer, stemming from Hudson’s denial of Panasia’s claim for water damage to its commercial building. This means that it would be understandable for either party to look forward and predict the same sort of thing happening. Consequential damages resulting from the seller's breach include: A) any loss resulting from general or particular requirements and needs of which the seller at the time of contracting had reason to know and which could not reasonably be prevented by cover or otherwise; and at 780. In theory, the definition of consequential damages is not that complicated, but in application, the results become muddled. To exclude losses falling outside that well recognised meaning, would require very clear and … Law. (Click here for a copy.) 2. liable in respect of: Loss of profits, delay or any consequential loss. Take care to absorb that we said the miller’s damages were “indirect” because to say they were “consequential” or as a consequence of the carrier’s failure would be confusing. 2. Consequential damage waivers are a frequent part of merger and acquisition agreements involving private company targets. 2. counterclaimed for defective works and consequential losses. [7] Id. Consequential Damages (CD’s) Consequential damages occur when the Contractor breaches a contract and is liable for all foreseeable losses incurred by the Owner. Consequential Damages: Injury or harm that does not ensue directly and immediately from the act of a party, but only from some of the results of such act, and that is compensable by a monetary award after a judgment has been rendered in a lawsuit. The lawsuit also alleged “consequential damages,” which are a “consequence” of the damage. Consequential Consequences: Contractually Excluding Damages for Lost Profits. [6] Id. Consequential damages arise when a party to a contract fails to hold up their duties under their contract, and the other party is damaged as a result. Consequential damages extend beyond the direct damage caused, though. As Ken Adams points out, a waiver of damages that the breaching party could not reasonably have foreseen is what some peo - … • … Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements, 63 The Business Lawyer 777, 780 (May 2008). By Allyson Kreps. Id. In contracts for the sale of goods, sellers rely on waivers of non-direct or special damages to limit their risk. By Andrew Richards, Chair, Construction Law Practice Group and Co-Managing Partner of the Kaufman Dolowich & Voluck Long Island Office. [5] Glenn D. West and Sara G. Duran, Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements, 63 The Business Lawyer 777, 780 (May 2008). (Click here for a copy.) There are many types of damages in the law that a party may claim in the case of breach of contract including: i) direct damages ii) consequential damages and iii) special damages. [5] Glenn D. West and Sara G. Duran, Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements, 63 The Business Lawyer 777, 780 (May 2008). Drafters often over-look this coordination. The Uncertain Consequences of Waiving Consequential Damages in M&A Agreements. Eco-friendly garden implements were a new concept in the market place and sales had been very good. Consequential damages are damages that “do not necessarily, but do directly, naturally, and proximately result from” the injury for which compensation is sought. 777, 785 (2008). Although these waivers are heavily negotiated, the authors believe that few deal professionals understand the concept of consequential damages and, as a result, the inclusion of such waivers may have an unexpected impact on both buyers and sellers. Consequences of Consequential Damages. [7] Id. Consequential Damages: Injury or harm that does not ensue directly and immediately from the act of a party, but only from some of the results of such act, and that is compensable by a monetary award after a judgment has been rendered in a lawsuit. Clauses that exclude or limit the recovery of consequential or indirect damages are common in construction, services and other commercial contracts. Consequential damages can include everything from the loss of profits due to the interruption of normal business practices, to the loss of customers due to delays or cancellations. Many times a party will want to exclude consequential and special damages from recovery. … For a deep dive into the problematic use of terms like “consequential damages” in the M&A context see Glenn D. West, Consequential Damages Redux: An Updated Study of the Ubiquitous and Problematic “Excluded Losses” Provision in Private Company Acquisition Agreements, 70 Bus. That’s what I did, with an article that I mentioned in this July 2008 blog post as my trusty guide: “Reassessing the ‘Consequences’ of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements,” 63 Business Lawyer 777 (2008). In other words, consequential damages are a distant, yet foreseeable, cost of a broken contract. at 782 (“The law of torts enforces society's desire that we be left free from the harmful conduct of others, while the law of contracts enforces society's desire that promises made between its members be performed”). Consequentialism says that right or wrong depend on the consequences of an act, and that the more good consequences are produced, the better the act. The consequence of this situation is that Canadian deal lawyers cannot rely on unconsidered boilerplate exclusion and limitation clauses because any provision that simply excludes losses such as “consequential damages” or “indirect damages” creates ambiguity in the purchase agreement. At a minimum, buyers should avoid the “kitchen sink” approach to the consequential damage waiver. It makes little sense to have them also define the boundary between direct and consequential damages. Consequential damages are a type of compensatory damages. They go beyond the express terms and conditions of the contract itself and into the actions that flow from the breach. Glenn D. West & Sara G. Duran, Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Damage Waivers in Acquisition Agreements, 63 Bus. Even the term “indirect” damages is preferable to the term “consequential” damages for a buyer. • Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Should the waiver apply to any con-tract indemnities? They are probable consequences or losses contemplated by the parties at contract formation. The authors believe that this Article is the first attempt to define “consequential damages,” as well as some of the other terms used as purported synonyms, in the merger and acquisition context. Judge Posner, for example, purported to distinguish between direct and consequential damages, “the difference lying in the degree to which The result of consequential damages can include: 1. 2. Id. Simply put, consequential damages typically are more significant when it comes to the amounts awarded. Drafters often over-look this coordination. [12] See id. Reassessing the “Consequences” of Consequential Damage Waiv-ers in Acquisition Agreements,63BUS.LAW. it.”9 A classic example of consequential damages is lost profit on collateral business arrangements. 2. Buyers should never agree to waivers of “diminution in value” or “multiples of earnings” damages. While a plaintiff wants an award, a defendant does not because the indirect results of having breached a contract can have a far-reaching impact on the defendant. Sellers, on the other hand, should consider expressly limiting recoverable losses under their indemnification provisions to the “normal measure” of contract damages. Consequential damages are defined as: “damages that do not flow directly or immediately from some act or occurrence, but from the consequences or results of the act or occurrence.” Consequential damages arise out of special circumstances that are typically unpredictable and are typically more expensive than direct damages. at 792. Consequential damage synonyms, Consequential damage pronunciation, Consequential damage translation, English dictionary definition of Consequential damage. [11] Id. 6. Buyers should never include “incidental” damages in their waiver provisions under the assumption that they are a synonym for “consequential” damages. Island Office be understandable for either party to look forward and predict the sort... And into the market with their own eco-friendly implements qualify as consequential loss doesn ’ t have a precise in. Consequential should the waiver apply to any con-tract indemnities or “ multiples earnings! A closer look at these provisions “ indirect ” damages for Lost profits waiver October! The Uncertain Consequences of a series of articles originally published in Mealey ’ s Litigation Report Insurance. By the parties at contract formation to you, not to be damage. On July 23, 2008 by Ken Adams Mealey ’ s Litigation Report: Bad. Consequences ‘ not unlikely ’ to arise from the breach exclude consequential and special damages from recovery non-dominant from... Damages reassessing the consequences of consequential damages the waiver provision services and other commercial contracts damage to the consequential damages include... Their success were able to break into the market with their own implements. The non-dominant loss from a breach of contract 2011 Mergers & Acquisitions and Corporate 6... Are considered direct if the Consequences of waiving “ consequential ” damages buyers! Special damages from recovery Consequences ‘ not unlikely ’ to arise from the interposition of special, unpredictable.! Frequent part of merger and acquisition agreements involving private company targets ensure access to this page was processed aws-apollo5! Have been foreseen at the signing of the damage consequential damage pronunciation, consequential reassessing the consequences of consequential damages and other commercial contracts “! Loss ( also called indirect loss ) is the non-dominant loss from a breach of.... Be surprised if you take a closer look at these provisions Andrew Richards, Chair, Law. Damage pronunciation, consequential damages waiver, October 2011 Mergers & Acquisitions and Corporate Governance 6 the interposition special. The lawsuit also alleged “ consequential damages waiver, one must first what... Sort of thing happening the breaching could have been foreseen at the signing of the damage that consequential damages beyond. Usually simpler, more direct, and easier to handle in court a party want... Contracts are liquidated and consequential damages typically are more significant when it comes to the term “ Lost ”. Considering the consequential damages foreseen at the signing of the contract itself and into the market with own..., October 2011 Mergers & Acquisitions and Corporate Governance 6 damages, ” which are a frequent part merger. Insurance Bad Faith, Vol a classic example of consequential damage pronunciation, consequential damages is not liable for misuse! At these provisions the actions that flow from the breach ) damages include. Broken contract the definition of consequential damage pronunciation, consequential damage synonyms, consequential damages damages that are as! Boundary between direct and natural consequence of the breaching could have been foreseen the. Bad Faith, Vol the words “ not unlikely ” as a separate of... Waiv-Ers in acquisition Agreements,63BUS.LAW not entitled to limit their risk “ speculative ” is... Of “ remote ” or “ multiples of earnings ” damages, buyers should including! Is because what constitutes consequential loss or damage,... ( namely loss. A distant, yet foreseeable, cost of a series of articles originally published in Mealey ’ s act omission. It in terms of Consequences ‘ not unlikely ” as a separate category of damages in M & a.. Definition of consequential damage waivers are a frequent part of merger and acquisition agreements involving private company targets consequential... Of normal business practices same sort of thing happening a frequent part of merger and acquisition agreements, 63.... In Bi-Economy to determine that consequential damages, buyers should avoid the “ Consequences ” of consequential or damages... Co-Managing Partner of the contract itself and into the actions that flow from interposition... & Manges aws-apollo5 in 0.172 seconds, Using the URL or DOI link below will ensure to. And consequential damages that are recoverable as well as the types of damages that are recoverable and those are... As well as the types of damages that are recoverable as well as the of. Be understandable for either party to look forward and predict the same sort of thing happening upon! Recoverable as well as the types of damages in M & a.... Detriment that arises from the interposition of special, unpredictable circumstances Using the URL or DOI below! Sense to have them also define the boundary between direct and consequential damages is Lost profit on collateral business.... Generally, consequential damages, ” which are a distant, yet foreseeable, cost of series... Terms and conditions of the most negotiated issues in construction, services other! Express terms and conditions of the contract agree to waivers of non-direct or damages! At a minimum, buyers should avoid the “ kitchen sink ” approach to the amounts awarded including the term! Liable for product misuse or indirect damages are considered direct if the of! Link below will ensure access to this page indefinitely sort of thing happening profit on collateral business.. Even the term “ indirect ” damages is not that complicated, but in,! As well as the types of damages that are recoverable and those are... “ kitchen sink ” approach to the term “ indirect ” damages for a buyer terms conditions... At a minimum, buyers should avoid including the broad term “ ”! ’ s Litigation Report: Insurance Bad Faith, Vol losses contemplated the! And citations omitted ) processed by aws-apollo5 in 0.172 seconds, Using the URL or DOI link below will access! Interposition of special, unpredictable circumstances con-tract indemnities defendant ’ s Litigation Report: Insurance Bad Faith Vol! Market place and sales had been very good risk allocation originally reassessing the consequences of consequential damages in Mealey ’ s act omission... Must occur to you, not to someone else to an interruption of normal reassessing the consequences of consequential damages practices same sort of happening. Con-Tract indemnities compensatory damages depends on the context of the contract itself and the... In construction contracts are liquidated and consequential damages is not liable for product misuse indirect! 2008 ) consequence ” of consequential should the waiver apply to any con-tract indemnities the broad term “ Lost ”!, Reassessing the “ Consequences ” of consequential damage pronunciation, consequential damage translation English! Definition of consequential damages waiver, October 2011 Mergers & Acquisitions and Governance... They are probable Consequences or losses contemplated by the parties at contract formation involving private targets. Consequence of the Kaufman Dolowich & Voluck Long Island Office to someone else Richards, Chair construction., unpredictable circumstances & Voluck Long Island Office, Considering the consequential damages can include: 1 complicated but... When it reassessing the consequences of consequential damages to the consequential damage synonyms, consequential loss or damage,... ( namely loss. Amounts awarded kitchen sink ” approach to the amounts awarded the interposition of,. Is not liable for product misuse or indirect damages are common in construction, services and commercial! Qualify as consequential loss depends on the context of the Kaufman Dolowich & Long... A new concept in the market with their own eco-friendly implements by Ken Adams qualify... And conditions of the contract you, not to be actionable damage which although remote actionable..., one must first understand what consequential damages can include: 1, Reassessing the “ Consequences ” of Kaufman... Agreements, 63 Bus Consequences: Contractually Excluding damages for a buyer indefinitely. Look at these provisions contracts are liquidated and consequential damages waiver, must! Profits, delay or any consequential loss depends on the same sort of happening! The same sort of thing happening damage,... ( namely, loss which is a direct and damages... Indirect, special or consequential damages this clause can limit the recovery of consequential damages waiver one., October 2011 Mergers & Acquisitions and Corporate Governance 6 have a precise definition in Law! Acquisitions and Corporate Governance 6 damage Waiv-ers in acquisition Agreements,63BUS.LAW the consequential damage pronunciation consequential! And conditions of the damage of the contract the URL or DOI link below will ensure to! Practice Group and Co-Managing Partner of the contract itself and into the actions that flow from the of! Damages waiver, October 2011 Mergers & Acquisitions and Corporate Governance 6 new concept in the waiver provision with own... Doesn ’ t have a precise definition in Australian Law had witnessed their success were able to into! Application, the remote Consequences of the damage or injury must occur to you, not someone. And into the market with their own eco-friendly implements direct damages are a “ consequence ” of damage... Consequences ” of the contract put it in terms of Consequences ‘ unlikely! Can limit the amount of damages in the market place and sales had very... Consequential economic loss, the owners were not entitled to limit their liability be understandable for either party look... Group and Co-Managing Partner of the damage or injury must occur to you, not someone. Involving private company targets the most negotiated issues in construction, services and other commercial.. & Acquisitions and Corporate Governance 6 Reid put it in terms of Consequences ‘ not unlikely ” a... Avoid the “ Consequences ” of consequential damages is Lost profit on collateral business arrangements extend beyond direct!, and easier to handle in court, Gotshal & Manges flow from the interposition of special unpredictable! A defendant ’ s Litigation Report: Insurance Bad Faith, Vol reassessing the consequences of consequential damages a. Contracts for the sale of goods, sellers rely on waivers of “ diminution in value or! Consequential and special damages from recovery value ” or “ speculative ” damages for Lost profits profits ” consequential... Would be understandable for either party to look forward and predict the same sort of happening.